Shit, if we're doing my lifetime achievement awards now.

C-Bench
1B-Murray or Pujols
2B-Morgan (you could cheat and put Rose or Carew at 2B they didn't have enough power to play first in my lineup)
SS-Ripken or Yount
3B-Brett
LF-Henderson (I'd like to put Yaz in there but I need a leadoff hitter)
CF-Griffey Jr.
RF-Dawson (only because Clemente died a couple of years before I started following baseball)

LHP-Carlton (had a 16 year stretch where he averaged 282 IP per year. Won 23 games and pitched 19 CGs at the age of 37)

RHP-Morris (most underrated pitcher in the last 25 years)

RP-Eckersley


While I'm thinking about it.

G-Patrick Roy
D-Bobby Orr
D-Ray Bourque (no complaints if you were to put Fetisov here)
LW-Valery Kharlamov
C-Wayne Gretzky
RW-Brett Hull