Right, it wouldn't be the first time someone put the squeeze on a guy by claiming pregnancy. Whether the condition actually existed or not is almost irrelevant in the sense that the mere possibility proves she had fluid exchanging sex with him, knowing his condition (regardless of how low his count was).

In terms of young, even if she was a mentally mature woman of 30, she would be young to him but no one has ever claimed that status of her that I am aware of. I'm too far removed from the day to day drama of stuff like that (by choice) so I generally don't take sides but John and family have shown me how reasonable they are time and again so of course I lean that way.