Plus he's a Ginger, plus a 22ish Grad Assistant and he walks in on the mastermind of "Linebacker U" butt-raping a child in the locker room he was banished to, to do grunt work. A lot of conflicting emotions there.
I'd like to think I'd be in the 50% fight crowd but then again I'm not a Ginger. I'd bet money whatever he told the new witness was said to make himself look better in his own eyes because he is kicking himself for not stopping it posthaste. McCreary has probably been kicking himself over this for years.