Ty Cobb, LF (.367, terrorist on basepaths, good glove)
Tris Speaker, CF (best defensive CF ever, most doubles, .345)
Babe Ruth, RF (Could do it all)
Lou Gehrig, 1B (RBI machine)
Napoleon Lajoie, 2B (They named the team after him, .338)
Luke Appling, SS (.310, great defense, long HOF career)
Mickey Cochrane, C (.320, long considered the best)
Brooks Robinson, 3B (For defense obviously, but he drove in runs)
Pitchers bat in real baseball.


Bill Dickey (Taught Berra)
Ivan Rodriguez (Maybe over Cochrane?)

Jimmie Foxx (Right-handed Ruth pinch hits and plays some 3B here)
Lou Boudreau (Leader, clutch)
Eddie Collins (Smart, good glove, good backup infielder here)
Ted Williams (Left handed bat off the bench)
Micky Mantle (If he had two good knees, and cut down his swing, ...)

Walter Johnson (greatest of all time)
Lefty Grove (31-4, smoking fastball, battled Johnson)
Cy Young (Dominated the league first 3-4 seasons it existed)
Bob Feller (Personal favorite gets here on merit, too)
Early Wynn (Won 300, great competitor)

Dennis Eckersley (Yes, another personal favorite who merits being here)
Rollie Fingers (Classic reliever)
Rube Waddell (Long relief when present and sober)
Waite Hoyt (Personal favorite, clutch, see '21 Series)
Sam McDowell (Smoke from the left side to set up the closers)

-Chuck, Vegetarian fanboy