GoodFella's sucks ass in Bay Ridge, Staten Island, anywhere, everything there is terrible, I think their pizza sucks. Grimaldi's is one of the best, but the waiting outside forever annoys the shit out of me.

Jim since we're from the same area (or you work in my area) go to Union Street (between Hicks & Columbia) called House of Pizza, excellent, one of the best and will always be, they havent changed in over like 75 years. They deep fry their calzones, they're perfection. And right across the street is Ferdinando's the place I told you that has Manhattan Special on tap. All their food is amazing. Got a bit pricey, but for 2 for lunch, you can easily rack up a 50-60.00 bill. When I was a kid, if you spent 10.00 that was alot and you got one of everything.
If you like Panelle (ground chickpeas) deep fried w/ricotta, shaved parmagiana on a roll its incredible, they also do it w/ potato croquettes, same way, they also have alot of sicilian delights. Outrageous, always in the books for being on the best restaurants in Brooklyn.