Just to settle things down, following is a list of posters whom I wanted banned at one time or another. I'm not saying I would have banned them or that they should have been banned or that I have or have not changed my opinion since then but here's a list off the top of my head going back all the way to 2004 for K1ng:

Smartt
Dr Pornz
Coochie Monster
Garfield
Kyoto
Lurids 1, 2, 3, etc.
Fatman
Rauol Duke
Moxie
DaBurglar
Papercut
Lou Cypher
Jim B
GonzoAnalGirl
ChuckSpears (for being a tony malice alt-id)
Freestylah

Now when I look back thru that list every one of them except for the Lurids and DrPornz added something important to the board that would be missing if they'd been banned. Also bjfan contributed nothing and hasn't been missed but I never wanted to ban him myself.

There has to be more. I'll add them as I think of them. Meanwhile post usernames you think should have been banned and you can be as ambiguous as you want as to your present feelings.