One thing I've noticed and been annoyed about while watching porn over the years is that not all directors are great on every release and it's unrealistic to expect it, but the one thing I look for is consistency. I'm not counting in current porn studs who are given the chance to direct. So, the question I'm posing out of curiosity is:

The award for most consistent should go to Ed Powers or Max Hardcore. Or most incontent?

Rodney Moore is not consistent, but over the years has done some really different stuff that later went "mainstream". And his skits with Wolf Savage were really funny.

new candidates announced:

I'll definitely take Rodney Moore over those last three clowns(that he's up against),for at least he looks like Howard Stern(even though he now has a beard to cover that fact up),uses real looking ladies(with no plastic surgery,nor fake boobies),and does everything---everything(with the exception of gay sex,and bodily fluids)---that one could ask for in their porn.

Jules Jordan does the same fuckin´ movie over and over and over. That´s not consistency, that´s BORING.

You forgot my favorite director - JOEY SILVERA.
This guys is the best hands down.

yeah I also left out Randy West, but I tried to limit the former porn studs gone gonzo for the sake of more traditional director-types, who knows....

Paul Thomas is a bore, Jim Holliday is a joke, Stoney Curtis is stupid, tho I can't remember them all.. :