Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/30/0803:13 PM
Rickey Henderson Andre Dawson Dave Parker(stats don't include all the runners Parker and Dawson threw out) Jim Rice Bert Blyleven (spent 3/4 of his career with epically shitty teams) Tommy John (they should at least put his elbow in the Hall of Fame) Jack Morris
I am on the fence about Dale Murphy and Lee Smith. I wouldn't protest if they were in, I wouldn't protest if they were out.
I'm the same "on the fence" as the UP above, about his picks. Maybe a little higher on Lee Smith. And I want Larkin to get in, but I wouldn't vote for Trammell, so I am a bit of a homer. If Blyleven would have had one great season, he'd be there.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/30/0804:27 PM
I couldn't care less if malcontents, ingrates and pains in the ass like Henderson, Rice and Parker ever make it to the Hall. I just hope the Veteran's Committee moves to elect someone among the living, namely Ron Santo. And I'm no Cubs fan.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/30/0808:12 PM
Quote: Results of the 2008 Post-1942 Players Ballot (48 votes needed for election): Santo (39 votes, 60.9 percent), Jim Kaat (38, 59.4 percent), Tony Oliva (33, 51.6 percent), Gil Hodges (28, 43.8 percent), Joe Torre (19, 29.7 percent), Maury Wills (15, 23.4 percent), Luis Tiant (13, 20.3 percent), Vada Pinson (12, 18.8 percent), Al Oliver (nine, 14.1 percent), Dick Allen (seven, 10.9 percent).
Of those on the Veteran's committee ballot, I would have voted for Santo & Oliva.
I like Kitty as a person and announcer, but like with Blyleven, I had no great "dread" of him. I like an "Oh SHIT!" element in a player. Someone you just don't want to see up against your team.
So, your team is in a pennant race and you have to win the big game and you see the has, say, Gibson, Drysdale, Koufax, Palmer, Hunter, Marichal, Carlton .... it's "OH Shit!"
Honestly I think Holtzman, McNally and Guidry, among others, were ALL better than either Katt or Burt. Anyway, I don't like compilers. Stats aren't everything.
Which is why I like Oliva. Sure his career was cut short, but when that guy was healthy he was great. He put up is numbers in the worst environment for hitters. When he was up in the big spot, the other team was afraid.
And, if the tying run was on, you didn't want to see Ron Santo up against you. I think playing in the 60s and 70s and thus not having the HUGE numbers has hurt him.
Sadly I don't think they vote on players again until 2010 [for 2011 induction]. And, no one was all that close this time. Maybe next time it'll be a whole different set of voters.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/31/0808:53 AM
Graig Nettles classic case of a guy who was great but in a totally subtle, all around everyday way. As third basemen go, he was one of the all time greats. HIS fielding was even more amazing than his hitting. He just got overshadowed by Brooks, and then George Brett and Mike schmidt.
Nettles was also funny as hell. And he is the answer toa trivia question: Who was the last yankee to win a Homerun title besides A-ROD and Reggie?
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/31/0809:11 AM
Nettles was my favorite player when I was a kid, especially after Bobby Murcer was traded. His fielding skills are certainly Hall-worthy.
I'll never forget all the home runs he hit in April of 78. I think he broke the AL record and tied the ML. I assume it no longer stands. I think it was later that year that his bat cracked and a bunch of superballs fell out and bounced off the plate and around the batter's box. I saw him play live hundreds of times between 73 and the early 80s. Nettles, Munson, Roy White and Mickey Rivers impressed me more than any other non-pitching Yankees in that era. Piniella, too, as a hitter and just based on crazy hustle.
And that record was for 32 homers in 76. 32! Those were the days!
"The more we lose, the more Steinbrenner will fly in. And the more he flies, the better the chance there will be for a plane crash."—Graig Nettles
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/31/0810:00 AM
Nettles SAVED the 1978 world series for the yankees. Game 3, the dodgers were leading the series 2-0, and they kept threatening to score and take a 3-0 lead in the series. But nettles made 5 (FIVE) totally impossible diving miraculous plays and throws AT THIRD BASE in the game, and robbed that fucking asshole steve garvey of at least 5 RBI. It is estimated that Nettles saved anywhere from 7 to 10 runs with his plays. And the thing was, he made those kinds of plays ALL THE TIME, everyday.
But people only wanted to remember him for his towering homeruns. He had 32 HR in 1976 to lead the league in a year when NO ONE hit any homeruns (Reggie was second that year with 27 dingers playing for BALTIMORE!) thurman won MVP in 1976, otherwise Nettles might have got it. Then, in 1977, Nettles had his BEST year ever when he hit 37 Homers and drove in 107 RBIs, finishing second in dingers to JIM RICE's 39. But 1977 was ROD CAREW's year as he flirted with .400 and hit .388
Nettles was Playoff MVP in 1981 when he single handed BEAT the Oakland A's in the ALCS sweeping them 3-0....Nettles drove in 10 RUNS in the 3 games.
My favorite quote from NEttles: in 1978 Spring training, Sparky Lyle, who had won the CY young award in 1977 as a reliever/spot starter, was griping about the yankees slamming him in the face bu signing Goose Gossage in the off season after Lyles record setting season as a reliever. No one could understand it, least of all Sparky. So nettles says to him "You went from Cy Young to Sayanora".
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/31/0810:52 AM
I'm a Yankee hater and the only 3rd baseman I've ever seen field better than Nettles was Brooks, and there wasn't all that much of a difference. [btw, I think Schmidt's the best all-around at the position I've seen].
The rubber ball thing was one of the funniest things I ever saw.
Pinella was the Yankee I least wanted to see up if the game was on the line [remember I'm rooting AGAINST the Yanks, so that's quite the compliment].
The only Yankee I've dreaded more EVER was Bernie. I think Bernie is the least appreciated Yankee, maybe of all time. I think that most of the people with the highest respect for Bernie are non-Yankee fans.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/31/0811:05 AM
Quote: I'm a Yankee hater and the only 3rd baseman I've ever seen field better than Nettles was Brooks, and there wasn't all that much of a difference. [btw, I think Schmidt's the best all-around at the position I've seen].
I was too young to see Brooks in his heyday, so nothing I saw live compared to Graig at third. As an all-round player I suppose you'd have to go with Schmidt, but I'd take Nettles over him, Brooks, Geo. Brett and Wade Boggs.
Quote: The rubber ball thing was one of the funniest things I ever saw.
Definitely, I wonder if that was actually before his big HR seasons. He claimed someone gave him the bat and he had no idea. Sure!
Quote: Pinella was the Yankee I least wanted to see up if the game was on the line [remember I'm rooting AGAINST the Yanks, so that's quite the compliment].
Yep. He was a great clutch hitter AND outfielder. He'd get to a lot of balls you wouldn't expect him to. And he was always good for a few ass-over-teakettle dramatic flips to keep things interesting. He had a really bad inner ear problem around 75 that did a job on his numbers.
Quote: The only Yankee I've dreaded more EVER was Bernie. I think Bernie is the least appreciated Yankee, maybe of all time. I think that most of the people with the highest respect for Bernie are non-Yankee fans.
For sure. Bernie was taken for granted. Munson was a dreaded batter, a lot of people forget that.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/31/0811:24 AM
As a catcher as a kid, Munson is one of my ALL-TIME favorites [plus Munson is my favorite aunt's maiden name]. He was tough and clutch. He was the only Yank to show up at the '76 WS, and he made quite a showing.
Sorry, Schmidt's the best. And, I HATE the Phillies, too.
Personally, I'd take Nettles over Brooksie for the intangibles alone. Remember he's the one who pointed out the pine-tar on Brett's bat to Billy. And, no "roids" in the WS like Brett ... I was never much of a Boggs fan.
[Nettles bat "exploded" in '74 at Shea - the Yankees home for 74-75 - in the second game of a double header ... he hit a homer in the first game, which the Yankees lost anyway].
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/31/0811:55 AM
[Nettles bat "exploded" in '74 at Shea - the Yankees home for 74-75 - in the second game of a double header ... he hit a homer in the first game, which the Yankees lost anyway].
Wow. That early?
For some reason I vividly recall watching Walt Williams, Jim Mason and someone I can't recall (maybe Bill Sudaikis) playing catch before batting practice along the first baseline that year at Shea. There was no one else on the field. I was wondering where in hell all the REAL Yankeees were. Then No Neck lightly tossed a ball into the stands over our heads there along the fence. And then another. Kid chaos of course ensued. He and Mason laughed and walked back to the dugout.
Walt looked just like this. Hell, maybe it was the same day.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/31/0812:38 PM
I remember in '93, I drove to Detroit to watch KC and the Tigers, in the old ballpark. It poured rain. I was standing in a corner in the walkway underneath, smoking a cigarette. Just as I was taking a puff, I heard the clacking of spikes on concrete, and George Brett walked by. He saw me taking a big drag off the cigarette, and gave me a disgusted look. He had decided to walk underneath, instead of in the rain, to get to the clubhouse. I had been on the fence with smoking, and quit about a week later.
Later the same night, I saw Cecil Fielder hit a ball over the 440 in dead center field. Then it poured rain again, so I left. On the way home, I heard Ernie Harwell say on the radio that the ball Cecil hit was one of only 3 he had ever seen hit out there.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/31/0803:32 PM
Nettles was great defensively and put up some good power numbers but anyone that would take him over Schmidt or Brett is flat out crazy. Did Sparky Anderson ever intentionally walk Graig Nettles with the bases loaded? (He did that once with Brett.)
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/07/0908:55 AM
I'm happy Whitey made it. A true baseball man, that changed the game before small ballparks and juice fucked it up.
Andre Dawson deserves to be in. 5 tool player that was crippled, figuratively and literally, by the shitty stadium in Montreal. I recently watched a tape of Ryne Sandberg's induction speech, very good one, and when he called on the Hawk to stand and take a bow, the guy could barely get out of his chair. I'd take him over Rice all day long.
Blyleven I think should be in. His only fault is that he played for shitty teams. He's up there in Ks, shout outs, complete games, and has a good win total. I think no one has lost more 1-0, 2-1 games than him.
Alomar- I don't like him as a person, but he was a good player. I don't know about first ballot, but he's going to get in there sometime.
McGwire-Fuck him.
Fred McGriff- Crime Dawg would have been one of the top sluggers of the past 20 years, if his stats weren't over shadowed by Steroid Stats. I don't think he'll make it in anytime soon, but he'd get my vote.
Larkin- I was never a big fan of his, but I wouldn't complain about him getting in.
Donnie Baseball- If his back injury happened at the end of his career, he'd be a lock. It happened in the middle and took part of his prime along with his power. You can't get in at first base with Gold Gloves. It pains me to say he'll never get in.
Murphy, Parker and Morris....Murphy and Morris will probably get in eventually through Veteran's Committee.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/06/1005:01 PM
Congrats!
2010 Voting Results
Player Votes 2010% 2009%
Andre Dawson 420 77.9% 67.0%
Less than 75% of vote, but still on ballot.
Bert Blyleven 400 74.2% 62.7%
Roberto Alomar 397 73.7% 1st year
Jack Morris 282 52.3% 44.0%
Barry Larkin 278 51.6% 1st year
Lee Smith 255 47.3% 44.5%
Edgar Martinez 195 36.2% 1st year
Tim Raines 164 30.4% 22.6%
Mark McGwire 128 23.7% 21.9%
Alan Trammell 121 22.4% 17.4%
Fred McGriff 116 21.5% 1st year
Don Mattingly 87 16.1% 11.9%
Dave Parker 82 15.2% 15.0%
Dale Murphy 63 11.7% 11.5%
Harold Baines 33 6.1% 5.9%
Less than 5%, will not be on next year's ballot
Andres Galarraga 22 4.1% 1st year
Robin Ventura 7 1.3% 1st year
Ellis Burks 2 0.4% 1st year
Eric Karros 2 0.4% 1st year
Kevin Appier 1 0.2% 1st year
Pat Hentgen 1 0.2% 1st year
David Segui 1 0.2% 1st year
Mike Jackson 0 0% 1st year
Ray Lankford 0 0% 1st year
Shane Reynolds 0 0% 1st year
Todd Zeile 0 0% 1st year
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/06/1008:14 PM
Happy for Dawson. I wonder how his career would have gone if he didn't play on the concrete of Montreal.
Looking back at the teams, I still cannot believe that the Expos of the late 70s/early 80s never could put it all together and win a pennant. I think their only "division" win was won in the split-season/strike year.
VERY, very happy Blyleven didn't get in. I HATE "compilers". That guy never impressed me. I never went into a game saying "uh oh, they'll got Blyleven on the mound!" Shouldn't get rewarded for just for being mediocre longer than anyone else.
..... but, I think this means Burt's all-but-enshrined in the near future.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/06/1009:05 PM
Man, Blyleven was on some shit teams. Yeah, Carlton was great on shit teams in the early 70's, but Blyleven put up those stats pitching against DH's. All those 1-0 and 2-0 losses. A quiet guy that spent his career in small markets. Even in those days the Yankees probably had more radio people covering the team than total media covering the Twins. If Blyleven never gets in, they should start pulling guys out. I'd take Bert on my team over Sutton any day.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/07/1004:06 PM
I can't stand Sutton either. Never feared him in a game either. Neither isn't the kind of guy you would want as your #1 starter.
Unlike, say a Jack Morris.
I have nothing against small market teams. It's not the issue.
Blyleven was NEVER one of the best at his position at anytime in his career. He won 20 games only once when winning 20 was a requisite. And, he wasn't limited to bad teams. The Twins of his early and late career were quite good, and he was with the Pirates when they were competing every year with the Phillies.
Bottomline, he's got very little "bold highlights" on his sheet. Never led the league in wins or era. Only once in strikeouts.
And, while his stats compare to Sutton's [who shouldn't be in the hall anyway, IMHO], the argument for his was the "300".
Burt doesn't have the "300". In fact, he's ~40 wins short of Sutton.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/07/1004:21 PM
Way, way, way too many votes for Edgar Martinez. No way he should be getting more votes than Parker, Murphy, and Mattingly. Martinez was just a 1990s version of Al Oliver.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/07/1010:57 PM
I LOVE DONNIE BASEBALL. If his injury was at the end of his career and catastrophic, like Puckett, he'd be in. Just too much mediocre at the end to get him in.
I hear you about compilers Fatty, not everyone can be Sandy Koufax though. Gimme your top 5 guys that should be thrown out of the Hall.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/08/1003:50 PM
Quote: not everyone can be Sandy Koufax though.
... and so not everyone belongs in the hall.
Quote: Gimme your top 5 guys that should be thrown out of the Hall.
I'd have to think about that.
As a caveat, since I think that there is more to a player than stats, I don't really have strong "he shouldn't be in" opinions on players I didn't see play.
Off the top of my head, in the last ~30 year of the writers the only one's that have bothered me are Hoyt Wilheim & Don Sutton. I wasn't a fan of Luis Aparicio's selection, but I never really watched him enough to have outrage at his selection.
I often raise an eyebrow at the selections that the veterans committee make, but most of them played before I was born. Of those that played that I have opinions about, Bill Mazeroski & Jim Bunning were certainly surprises. But, maybe their careers were over by the time I paid attention to them.
But, certainly on Sutton and Blyleven, I saw their careers. If my team was playing a must win game and you told me that other pitcher was Sutton or Blyleven, I wouldn't worry one bit.
Not like if it were Gibson or Marichal or Drysdale or Catfish, etc.
Hell Vida Blue or David Cone scare me way more than Don or Burt.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/08/1009:24 PM
Yes, the Old Timer's Committee has done horrendous things in the past. The one guy from the Gas House Gang Cardinals, politiced his way to getting a bunch of his buddies in.
Bert Blyleven
Roberto Alomar
Jack Morris
Barry Larkin
Lee Smith
Edgar Martinez
Tim Raines
Mark McGwire
Alan Trammell
Fred McGriff
Don Mattingly
Dave Parker
Dale Murphy
Harold Baines
Carlos Baerga
Jeff Bagwell
Bret Boone
Kevin Brown
John Franco
Juan González
Marquis Grissom
Lenny Harris
Bobby Higginson
Charles Johnson
Al Leiter
Tino Martinez
Raúl Mondesí
John Olerud
Rafael Palmeiro
Kirk Rueter
Benito Santiago
B. J. Surhoff
Larry Walker
I really hope Larkin makes it, and I think he will. Steroids changes the equation, I always said 300 wins, 500 homers, or 3000 hits should be automatic, but McGwire and Palmeiro rightly don't have a chance. Alomar will get in this year. Possibles are Blyleven, Bagwell, and Larry Walker, but I wouldn't vote for any of them.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/01/1109:57 AM
Larkin was a china doll. He had 4 years of over 150 games played. Jeter has played under 150 3 times, one of those years was 149, another 148. Larkin was not the hitter Jeter is. Never over 200 hits, below .300 lifetime, and has 3 more years on Derek to make stats like doubles, runs, RBI, homers looks closer than they actually are. And there is no different era excuse in comparing these two.
I'm admittedly biased, I've never been a big fan of Larkin, and I'm a Yankee lifer. I just put the guy in the Perennial All Star category, just not HOF. I don't see the guy have the intangible qualities of say Ryne Sandberg to over come being a step down in #'s. Only my opinion, I could be wrong, and I wouldn't complain as much about Larkin getting in as Rice, that guy only had 4 Hall worthy years, playing in a hitters park.
Alomar is an asshole, but deserves to get in.
If Mac and Raffy ever get in, their plaques should hang in the urinal.
Another guy for the Hall of the Very Good: Tim Raines. I guess in 87 or 88 he got hurt and it took him out of the Hall chase, but from 81 until then the guy was f'n good. Look at 1981, guy stole 71 bases in 88 games. WOW. Guy struck out more than he walked once in his career, even with all them years of hanging on at the end.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/09/1202:45 PM
Guys like McGriff get shafted by all them dudes juice #s. Fred never accused or suspected, and he put up 30hr/year for a decade, when 30 was a slugger, not something a 2nd baseman was doing every year.
Biggio going in would be good for Houston, cause Bagwell never gonna sniff the Hall.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/09/1204:07 PM
Does Piazza make it? Or do the rumors spread by Yankee's fans taint his image still? He's happily married to a Penthouse pet and has a kid, yet rumors by Yankee's fans forced him to actually give a press conference to say he wasn't gay. To me, the steroid thing might be the same situation.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/09/1311:17 AM
Yeah, I don't blame the writers. Biggio will get in, but there are still many writers that won't vote for a guy on the first ballot unless he is an upper echelon guy. Biggio is certainly deserving, and will get in eventually, but he isn't a Seaver/Bench/Reggie type legend.
Next year you get Maddux and Glavine, and maybe Torre as a manager, so the Steroid Bunch will continue to take a back seat.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/10/1308:52 PM
If he could turn it down 15-20% it would be ok, because he IS knowledgeable, but the thought that he is infallible gets tiresome. He needs a partner to mix it up, preferably not Mad Dog. That guy is an annoying elitist and I've been happy not hearing black guys call in to argue that he is a racist, which he is. Andre Rison, Andre Dawson, he calls them Ann-dre. Andre Agassi is On-dre as it should be. That is just one example.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/11/1306:17 AM
Originally Posted By: Jerkules
Yeah, I don't blame the writers. Biggio will get in, but there are still many writers that won't vote for a guy on the first ballot unless he is an upper echelon guy. Biggio is certainly deserving, and will get in eventually, but he isn't a Seaver/Bench/Reggie type legend.
Next year you get Maddux and Glavine, and maybe Torre as a manager, so the Steroid Bunch will continue to take a back seat.
Other than Palmeiro, Biggio is the first player with over 3,000 hits not to get elected in his first year of eligibility since Paul Waner in 1951. Frank Thomas is also on the ballot next year.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/19/1310:49 PM
Aw shit. God Bless Stan the Man.
Who is the Greatest Hitter Alive now? Willie Mays gets Greatest Living Ball Player since DiMaggio's death, so I wouldn't use him for hitter. Ted Williams was the hitter before Stan.
I don't know if I can go with Gwynn (.338), cause he had no pop, but the only other real candidate is Pujols, and his career aint over, average can go down. Aaron did bat .305 for his career, but has few seasons where his BA pops out at you.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/20/1306:48 AM
George Brett? If you eliminate Tony Gwynn then you are also eliminating Rod Carew and Wade Boggs. Brett did have some pop. You have to consider his home ball park is basically Death Valley for home run hitters and was even more so in the 1970s and 1980s.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/20/1307:51 AM
It pains me to call someone the Greatest Living Hitter who only batted .305 on their career though (Brett, Aaron).
I may have to go with Gwynn. His first year in the majors he only played in 54 games and hit .289. Over the next 19 years he never hit below .309, won 8 batting titles, had 7 seasons hitting over .350 (including 4 in a row at ages 34-37), and he only struck out 430 times in 20 years. Lifetime avg is .338.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/21/1311:17 AM
I'm just going to treat this as the baseball thread. He might not be a superstar, but he's still the face of the New York Mets. I saw David Wright just announced his engagement to this hot bitch. She even has a cool name: Molly Beers.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/21/1312:09 PM
Jesus Christ, look at how thin that fuck pig is on the side view.
Wright is a solid player that had a ton of responsibility dumped on him right as he was brought to the majors. I'm glad the Mets recognized that and paid the man. He may not be a superstar, but if he stays healthy, I could see him hitting enough numbers to get in the HOF (3000hits, 1500RBI, etc). I'd be surprised if he gets near 30hr again with that stadium though.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 02/18/1308:08 AM
Hate to set myself up to be wrong, but Maddux, Glavine, Smoltz, Randy Johnson, Biggio, Ichiro. I'm on the fence about Chipper Jones being a HOFer, but I don't think there were any rumors or reasons connecting him to PEDs. Vlad Guerrerro?
Now with guys getting dimed out in the Yankees & Mets locker rooms peddling PEDs, it does cast a pall over Jeter and Piazza, but I don't think there is any reason to think Mariano did them, and he is a lock first ballot guy.
With A-Rod coming out of Seattle, and Jay Buhner there hitting 40 HRs, along with him completely falling apart in Cincy, I have to lump Griffey Jr in with the steroid guys. If it is unfair, so be it, but if he wasn't juicing, then him and all the other guys that were playing clean should have made a bigger stink about the scum that was.
Personally, Pettitte is the guy that used em that hurts the most. He gets a partial pass from me, because he admitted it, but it still taints the memory of a great big game pitcher.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 02/18/1309:11 AM
Baseball's record book is revered like the bible. NFL, NBA, NHL have all gone through changes in the game that have turned their record books upside down. The MLB record book was fairly consistent from the 1920's to the steroid era. Only major change in the game was the lowering of the mound when pitching became too dominant in the late 60's. 60HRs was touched 2x in 70years, then surpassed 6x in three years, all by guys that juiced.
I can write off pitchers doctoring the baseball and corked bats as gamesmanship, because they aren't used everyday, in all situations. The effects of Juice and HGH are an everyday thing that hurts the integrity of the game.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 02/18/1309:35 AM
Come on.
In another sport, Armstrong doped; I didn't follow the shit, but that seems to be what happened or at least what people seem to think.
He won a lot because he probably lived his sport and had some of the best medical advice at his disposal. These doctors most likely got hired by teams who have sponsors and those like winners very much.
It isn't that far-fetched an idea to me that professional athletes just have to perform in the eyes of these people allowing them to compete on the level they strive for. It wouldn't be absurd to think that long-term health ethically's considered secondarily when opposed to short-term performance financially.
All of this is transferable.
While the idea of competitive sports is a noble one, there seems to be an advantage to know how what is changed in the athlete's body to whatever else and how which test would be able to prove this or not.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 02/18/1311:11 AM
Armstrong would get IV's of low doses of PEDs right after doing his piss tests, and claimed they were part of his cancer treatment. That is kinds like how they do shit in Horse Racing. The horse gets a shot of X amount, Y days before the race, so the after race test doesn't show a high enough level of Steroids or pain killers to turn up hot.
The top guys are all paid well, for them it is more for ego than greed.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 02/18/1309:32 PM
Originally Posted By: Jerkules
Hate to set myself up to be wrong, but Maddux, Glavine, Smoltz, Randy Johnson, Biggio, Ichiro. I'm on the fence about Chipper Jones being a HOFer, but I don't think there were any rumors or reasons connecting him to PEDs. Vlad Guerrerro?
Now with guys getting dimed out in the Yankees & Mets locker rooms peddling PEDs, it does cast a pall over Jeter and Piazza, but I don't think there is any reason to think Mariano did them, and he is a lock first ballot guy.
With A-Rod coming out of Seattle, and Jay Buhner there hitting 40 HRs, along with him completely falling apart in Cincy, I have to lump Griffey Jr in with the steroid guys. If it is unfair, so be it, but if he wasn't juicing, then him and all the other guys that were playing clean should have made a bigger stink about the scum that was.
Personally, Pettitte is the guy that used em that hurts the most. He gets a partial pass from me, because he admitted it, but it still taints the memory of a great big game pitcher.
What about Frank Thomas? He's eligible next year. Another future possibility could be Trevor Hoffman.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 02/19/1305:56 AM
I like Frank Thomas, but I think he's going to get lumped into the user category. Though if you look at his #'s it was his batting average that tailed off during his career, not so much his HRs. I'd vote for him and I'd vote for Piazza, because there is nothing firm on either of them.
If Hoffman makes it, it will take him a couple years. To show how impressive Mariano is, his career ERA is 0.66 lower than Hoffman's, and Hoffman pitched in the NL West, not AL East.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 02/22/1307:42 PM
I tell ya what, considering he played 3rd for most of his career, then ya he is a HOFer. I still don't think he is first ballot though. That's not trying to knock him, it is just to say he isn't Schmidt or Seaver or Bench or Carlton.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 03/27/1306:44 PM
Yep. Sometimes I type like he speaks. There are 2 Twitter parody accts that do a good job. At it. One guy is good w/ the photoshops. I've seen tgat guyquoted on the Daily News' last page.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 04/01/1306:18 PM
Interesting Opening Day. Yanks got shit holed, Mets showed life. Harper became the youngest to homer 2x in the opener and Kershaw became the second guy to hit a homer and throw a shut out. Hopefully all signs of an interesting year.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 04/01/1308:53 PM
CC usually is a warm weather/second half pitcher.
Yankees got problems this year. 1/2 there starting line up is hurt right now. Jeter, Granderson, Tex, and A-Roid. Take that kind of production out of any line up and it turns to shit. I hope A-Roid is out for the season. Jeter is a couple weeks. Grandy is May/June. Tex, who knows.
They can't throw money around, because under 189million next year means when they go over the luxury tax level again they will pay 17% tax instead of 50%. That is a whole lot of money staying in Steinbrenner pockets instead of going into the pockets of the Marlins and Pirates owners.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 04/01/1309:07 PM
Originally Posted By: Jerkules
CC usually is a warm weather/second half pitcher.
All true. But, when healthy, he's been a GREAT big game pitcher. A stop the bleeding pitcher.
He did none of that in the ALCS and again today, with everyone on the DL, he didn't step it up. I find it troubling.
A-Rod isn't A-Rod. Tex might not be Tex. Grandy is playing for a contract ... with the 189 limit, he won't be back with the Yanks in 2014. And, no one knows what Jeter has left.
If they don't make the playoffs, unlikely but possible, then I can't see them sticking to the 189 plan. They can't punt two years. Especially with Mo gone and maybe Jeter, too.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 04/01/1309:14 PM
My Mets are in full PUNT. It's ALL about 2014 or 2015 or whenever.
But, they are going to be TERRIBLE.
They lost their two best pitchers of the 1st half last year, the only half they were competitive in. Dickey was traded for catchers of the future. Santana is done.
They have no OF. They have Wright. A passable ML SS in Tejada. A possible gem C in D'Arnaud. Maybe they can get Ike back to 2010-11 form, but I doubt it.
It's ALL about their young pitchers. I remember the lost years of Generation K. You remember all the hype of Joba-Hughes-Kennedy. These things don't often come to pass. They did for the Mets in 69. They did again in 86. It's a lottery ticket to think that's the panacea. But, all we've got at the moment is that lottery ticket. And, all the numbers have to come up big.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 05/25/1310:03 AM
If it doesn't offend anyone I'm going to treat this as a general baseball thread.
Everyone feel free to rate just how bad of a call this was last night and why the fuck are none of the talking heads on ESPN talking about it. (My theory is because it clearly shows their fucking golden boy Mike Trout getting thrown out while trying to steal second only to have umdouchenozzlepire Marty Foster call him safe) Only ended up costing the Royals three runs and the game last night.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 05/25/1302:27 PM
ESPN loves their stars. I thought several of them were going to join al Queda after triple-crown winner Cabrera "stole" the MVP from Trout.
You win a triple crown, you lead you team to the playoffs and you didn't deserve the MVP?
I don't get their logic.
This is the same network that was still slurping up Bonds after it was CLEAR he was a juicer. I'm surprised they don't have a reporter on Favre's lawn. Or on Tebow's.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 05/26/1312:55 PM
This fucking douchefuck Marty Foster needs to get superkicked in the cunt. In addition to costing the Royals the game Friday night he threw out Chris Getz for arguing over a call at first yesterday and he just threw out Billy Butler from the dugout for arguing balls and strikes.
You fucking arrogant twat string. No one is coming to the ball park to watch you blow calls and throw people out of the game.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 05/26/1311:12 PM
Foster's crew managed to make one more atrocious call and one highly questionable decision. With two out Royals batter hit a ground ball to Trumbo who was playing about ten feet or so off first. Trumbo jogs over to the bag and then goes on to the dug out. Umpire rules that Trumbo never stepped on the bag and calls the Royals batter safe. Replay clearly shows Trumbo stepped on the bag. Sciosia comes out and blows a gasket. Immediately after a Fox Sports Kansas City mic picks up Sciosia say fuck you to Foster from the dugout but Foster doesn't run him. (Royals, being managed by Yost, end up with men on first and third with two outs and the tying run at the plate. Yost uses some scrub just called up from Omaha who was hitting .194 in AAA as a pinch hitter which results in a predictable ground out to the shortstop.)
Ninth inning same score two runners on and one out Jeff Francouer(who was put in to replace Butler) at the plate. Swings and misses at strike three and is called out by Foster who was behind home plate today . Francouer then argues after the call that he foul tipped the pitch and asks Foster to check for pine tar on the baseball. Foster gets the ball, looks at it and changes the call to a foul tip. Sciosia goes even more ballistic at Foster and gets tossed. Francouer, with his extraordinary ability to swing at any pitch located on the outside corner of the western hemisphere then flies out to the center fielder. Angels get the next batter to end game and hopefully Marty Foster's umpiring career. I am absolutely 1000% percent certain that Sciosia's head would have exploded Scanners style in the club house had Francouer homered on the next pitch.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 05/26/1311:22 PM
Stat of the day home runs hit since May 15.
Chicago Cubs pitchers-3 entire Kansas City Royals roster-2 (both by Miguel Tejada of all people)
If you read the post above me you might notice that Ned Yost replaced Billy Butler with Jeff Francouer at the DH spot when Butler was thrown out of the game yesterday. You might also notice that Yost used a backup catcher who was just called up from Omaha last night to replace Salvador Perez (whose grandmother died yesterday ) and who was hitting .194 in AAA ball to pinch hit with two men on while down 5-2 in the 8th inning yesterday. I know you are wondering exactly what LaRussaian manuever Yost used to put Tejada in since he did not use him in either of those situations. The answer is none. Tejada was still on the bench when the game was over. The loud crack you heard late Sunday afternoon (about 4:50pm CDT) was me ramming my head through the dry wall in my apartment.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 05/27/1308:29 AM
My stat of the day for the Mets:
Dillon Gee became the first pitcher in Mets history to allow a homer to the opposing pitcher in back-to-back appearances.
Last night, Shaun Marcum became the third pitcher to have a 12-strikeout, no-walk game in which he got a no-decision this season, joining Matt Harvey of the Mets, King Felix.
The last team to have a pair of pitchers get no-decisions, despite a 12-strikeout, no-walk effort, in the same season was the 1967 Cincinnati Reds.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 09/28/1306:08 AM
I love Jeter, but he is way easier to replace than Mo. Or Jorge for that matter. Jeter was the face of the franchise, but never should have been captain. O'Neil was the vocal leader of the team, then it was Posada. If Jeter was such a great captain, then the team would not have had to bring in "clubhouse guys" such as Swisher and Sabathia.
re New House: It is going on in all sports. The long time, "real fan" season ticket holders are priced out to make way for corporate tools. In turn, you get dead crowds who spend more time at the Hard Rock Cafe than watching the game. New Giant Stadium is the same way. You can't tell at Barclays, because when the Nets played in NJ, 9 outta 10 times they were lucky to fill the lower bowl.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 09/28/1306:45 AM
Nah, I think they are set to go with David Robertson next year.
Paper today is saying Cano wants 10 years $305. Him and Jay Z must be huffing each other's farts to come up with that. Says the Dodgers are not even going to make an offer. I would tell him 5/$125 and if he walks out the door w/o signing it is going to be 5/$120 when he comes back. Yankees are going to be bad for a couple years. They can be bad with him or without.
P.S. I bet a dollar to a donut Jay Z sent Riahanna to Cano's hotel room as an incentive to sign w/ his new agency. That drug addled mess would do anything Jay Z tells her to.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 09/28/1303:21 PM
Someone needs to explain three things to Cano.
1. Only two players in history have got that kind of contract. 2. Rodriguez and Pujols were both way better at the time they got that money than Cano is today. 3. Those contracts torpedoed the teams that signed them.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/09/1312:39 PM
#'s 3,4,&5 on the all time wins list for managers, all 3 are deserving. Big ups to Brooklyn!, for Mr. Torre.
Of the players, Maddux will challenge Seavers mark for Highest percentage of votes. Glavine, Thomas and Biggio should get in, I don't know if they all will this year, but I listed them in order of likelihood.
This is Jack Morris' final year on the ballot. He will go in within the first couple years he is on the Veteran's Committee ballot. He is borderline, but the most dominant pitcher of his era and that 10inning shutout in the World series is legendary.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/09/1304:16 PM
I know it's dumb, but I still think of Joe Torre in a Cardinal uniform, listening to him play with Jack Buck and Mike Shannon doing the play-by-play. Maybe no less silly than remembering Yogi Berra grew up with Joe Garagiola on The Hill in St. Louis.
Biggio and Piazza have a decent chance, but I remain wary after that little hissy fit the BBWA writers threw last year. I would doubt any other second-year players make the cut. I wish CrimeDog McGriff would get in, if for no other reason than his passionate endorsement of the Tom Emansky instructional videos.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/09/1309:44 PM
Yes Glavine should be in, but there is a section of the BWAA who thinks first year votes are for the elite of the elite. That may hold Glavine back. Also, I wonder if him and Maddux are sick of each other.
McGriff is the guy I think most effected by steroid #s. When he started out, Chili Davis and Jeffery Leonard hitting 22HR was a slugger. Crime Dog hit that 30+ a year consistently, and didn't spike up when everyone else started juicing. I think he is more of a Hall of Famer than Jim Rice.
I remember when Stienbrenner was ridiculed for hiring Joe. Best move the man ever made.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/09/1310:43 PM
I recall an old Dennis Leary comedy bit: "I think Billy Martin summed it up best when he said, 'It's OK, I'll drive.'" Recall when Seinfeld did a spoof of Steinbrenner and he threatened to fire Buck Showalter, then retraced, "Wait, you didn't hear that from me." Than the real George canned him just the same.
Some of these guys will be off the ballot soon. But Jerkules is right, the veteran's committee will find a place for them soon enough.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/11/1306:18 AM
I had an argument on another internet forum about a week ago who thought that Tim Raines should be a lock. I pointed out to him that it pretty much took him over 20 years to accomplish what Ichiro did in ten (minus the MVP, Rookie of the Year, and 10 Gold Gloves that Raines never did accomplish). Guy's only counter argument is career OBP. That's the drawback of all these Sabermetric geeks these days. All they look at are the numbers. They never actually watch the players play.
Raines was a very good but not great player who seemed to spend half his career on the disabled list. Ichiro should be a first ballot HoFer who put up ridiculous numbers for a decade considering he was 27 when he first played in the majors. Raines was basically a more often injured Willie Wilson with more power.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/11/1306:48 AM
I like Raines. It seemed like every time the Yankees had a late inning rally to win a game in 1996 it was Raines starting it, followed by Jeter advancing him and Bernie brining them home. Dude isn't a HOFer.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/26/1404:15 PM
Randy, Pedro, Biggio.
To start the argument before someone mentions him, Smoltz is not a Hall of Famer. Dude only had 1 20win season, and 2 others with more than 15 wins, on a team that was perennially one of the best in baseball.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/27/1406:23 PM
That's ridiculous. He only had one 20 win season because he spent five years in his prime as a closer. If he is starting those years his overall stats become better than Glavine's. Your argument makes a better case against Cox being in the Hall of Fame than it does against Smoltz
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/27/1411:56 PM
He spent that time as a closer because he was brittle, and it was only 3 full seasons. There was a 1/2 season before that, when he came back from Tommy John surgery.
So what, if he would have started those years, and some how remained healthy, he would have gotten to 250wins, and still been way outside the qualifications for a HOFer.
His only HOF qualification is being the #3 pitcher on TBS. There are a bunch of pitchers of his era that were much better than him, as displayed that he was only top 3 in Cy Young voting 2x.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 09/23/1508:32 AM
Come on, bro. When Yogi gets to heaven, you think he's asking for a Mets cap? This picture says it all about Yogi's career. I can't tell which one has the "5" on it to commemorate the 5 in a row they won.
Here is an article about his time in the Navy. He was a gunner's mate on a "rocket boat" during the D-Day Invasion.
Part of the job was to shoot down any plane “that flew beneath the clouds,” Berra said. “One of the first ones we got was one of our own. They were yelling at us, ‘What the hell are you doing?’
“And the way those waves were sending us up and down, we had to be careful we didn’t shoot each other.”
In the later hours, the boats circled back and exchanged more gunfire. In the days after the landing, they patrolled the coast, still being strafed by the enemy and returning fire. Berra remembers firing his “twin 50” into a German gun nest ensconced in a hotel on Utah Beach. “I think I might have got a couple of them,” he said with the little laugh that punctuates much of what he says.
Posted by: Anonymous
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 09/23/1504:43 PM
Originally Posted By: Jerkules
Come on, bro. When Yogi gets to heaven, you think he's asking for a Mets cap?
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 10/22/1507:32 AM
Congrats on the World Series, Steezo. I'm a Yankees fan, but I don't hate the Mets, just like to tweak their fans from time to time.
The team is great and if the pitching holds up, they gonna get a ring. I'm happy for the fans, but the Wilpons winning irks me. I don't like that family.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 10/22/1507:51 AM
I generally don't bet on baseball because I don't want to jinx my team. I'm still convinced my secretly Dad bet on the Mets/Yankees Series in 2000 and that's why the Mets lost. But I do bet every year with a friend of mine about the Mets regular season. Usually it's the number of wins in the current season, but this year it was whether they would make the playoffs. I finally won the bet for a change and my friend owes me a steak dinner, although he's trying to say we later changed that to a round of drinks and a table dance at the Bush Co. I don't remember changing the bet, but I'll probably go along with it.
Like or dislike the Wilpons, they got majorly screwed over by Bernie Madoff. I think they lost half a $billion. The (fake) returns on their investments were the reason they structured player contracts the way they did. It made sense to invest the money with Madoff and get 10-15% returns on it and then pay the payer deferred payments later.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 10/22/1510:30 AM
Originally Posted By: Steezo
I generally don't bet on baseball because I don't want to jinx my team. I'm still convinced my secretly Dad bet on the Mets/Yankees Series in 2000 and that's why the Mets lost. But I do bet every year with a friend of mine about the Mets regular season. Usually it's the number of wins in the current season, but this year it was whether they would make the playoffs. I finally won the bet for a change and my friend owes me a steak dinner, although he's trying to say we later changed that to a round of drinks and a table dance at the Bush Co. I don't remember changing the bet, but I'll probably go along with it.
Like or dislike the Wilpons, they got majorly screwed over by Bernie Madoff. I think they lost half a $billion. The (fake) returns on their investments were the reason they structured player contracts the way they did. It made sense to invest the money with Madoff and get 10-15% returns on it and then pay the payer deferred payments later.
They got screwed over by their own egos, thinking they were the smartest people around, investing everything they could with the smartest investor around, and not doing their due diligence.
Real estate bubble bursting hurt em badly also. Both happened as they were sinking money into the new stadium.
Anyway, that pitching staff looks unstoppable. Will only get better next year when Wheeler comes back from Tommy John in June.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 10/25/1505:58 PM
I'd probably have better luck wrangling a Kardashian.
Here's something for Fangraphs and Baseball Perspective to chew on. Ned Yost will be managing the American League in the All-Star Game in back to back years.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 10/25/1508:47 PM
Everything points to this being a good matchup. The Mets have flame-throwing control pitchers and KC has contact hitters who can hit the fastball. As far as the offense, the Mets are a new team since the beginning of August and actually are a pretty good team to hit with the DH in the American League games. We have some great defensive players and sometimes have to sit some of our offensive guys to play them. Cuddyer, Uribe, Flores and Duda could prove crucial in the AL games. And Cespedes will be batting against some pitching he may have seen in the past, compared to the NL clubs he's faced recently (which he has hammered anyway).
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 10/26/1504:53 PM
I still can't believe all of this (World Series trip) is happening. I feel like maybe I died and don't know it or I'm in a coma and having a dream. I told my brain to put a live elephant into my dream so I know to try to wake myself up. So far no elephants.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 10/28/1511:28 AM
Rear Admiral puts on this horse and pony tale about living outside of the U.S. for tax purposes. Thanks to last night we now know the real story. He is living outside of the U.S. so he can get someone decent announcing the World Series instead of Buck and Reynolds.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 10/30/1511:14 PM
Thor!!!! Huge win tonight for my Mets. My eyes and face are burning from the wind, my hands are sore from clapping, and my throat is hoarse. Loved it from the first (purpose) pitch on. Syndergaard pitched a real gem and we're right back in this thing! I think that long layoff had a big impact on the Mets bats and now that they seem back on track, I think they have a real chance. Amazin'!
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 10/31/1510:24 PM
Clippard couldn't throw strikes and Murphy couldn't field and the team overall couldn't hit except for Conforto, but it was a fun game for the first 7 innings at least. And I got a game ball after Bartolo Colon got the last out in the 6th. Someone unseen from the dugout tossed it right to me. Maybe it was Colon since he was looking right at me when he left the field and saw I was pointing at him and cheering. Also I saw Jerry Seinfeld walking in and out of the Delta Sky Club after the game. I think he was picking up his wife and kid from the private lounge area.
Random New Yorker walking by, yelling to KC fans: So what!?!?!? You aren't even from Kansas!!! You're from Missouri!!!
Random New Yorker walking the other way: So what is Kansas somehow better than Missouri?
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 11/01/1507:06 AM
They should give an MVP for batting coaches. I've never seen a team foul off so many two strike pitches as the Royals. Almost every at-bat has been a struggle for the Mets pitching staff.
Tonight, I get to see the first Mets game ever played in November, so that's something. And we have 3 aces lined up as starters, so it's not impossible.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 11/01/1510:49 PM
Harvey was so great tonight. My hands are swollen and the skin is splitting from clapping and my voice is shot from cheering him on. Having said that, they should've only given him 1 batter in the 9th before bringing in Familia. And for how great they were in getting the Mets to the Series, I'll be surprised if either Murphy or Cespedes are on the team next year. Shocked if Cespedes is back, actually.
Not too many positives from tonight's game, although I did make the Jumbotron sometime during the middle innings, cheering after Murphy completed a double play (without booting the ball for a change).
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 11/02/1512:17 AM
Originally Posted By: Jerkules
My condolences, Steezo.
Congrats TUP. You love Ned Yost now, huh?
You mean the manager with the best playoff game winning percentage (minimum 20 games managed in playoffs) in the history of Major League Baseball? (Steps away from computer to listen to the chorus of Sabernerds bashing their heads into walls as they read that)
The Royals are the Michael Myers of baseball. You can throw them off a cliff, set them on fire, electrocute them, run them over with a car, drop a piano on them and leave them for dead. Then when you think they are finished and you turn your back on them they disembowel you with a butcher knife.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 11/02/1508:39 AM
Originally Posted By: Steezo
Harvey was so great tonight. My hands are swollen and the skin is splitting from clapping and my voice is shot from cheering him on. Having said that, they should've only given him 1 batter in the 9th before bringing in Familia. And for how great they were in getting the Mets to the Series, I'll be surprised if either Murphy or Cespedes are on the team next year. Shocked if Cespedes is back, actually.
Not too many positives from tonight's game, although I did make the Jumbotron sometime during the middle innings, cheering after Murphy completed a double play (without booting the ball for a change).
Yeah, Mets aint paying Cespides $20+million, nor Murphy $12-15. They better drop the dime on some sort of offense though, because they gonna run out of b-level prospects to use as trade bait at the deadline.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 11/02/1508:51 AM
KC's scouting report had a big impact as well: Make d'Arnaud throw the ball; make Duda throw the ball. I don't think our catcher caught anyone stealing 2nd this series and if Duda makes that throw in the 9th, we're playing another game tomorrow.
I guess we in the crowd are partly to blame for the 9th inning. We had Harvey so pumped up he couldn't throw a strike. And the crowd just wouldn't stand for him not at least starting the 9th. But, like I already said, you have to yank him after he walks the first guy up in the 9th.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 11/02/1508:05 PM
I have a lot of respect for the KC team. I didn't enjoy having so many of their fans at Citi Field for the last two games, but I can't blame them for coming after winning the first 2 at home.
Random New York observation: If you were to guess the demographics of the city based on the crowd at Citi Field, you would think it was still mostly white, Irish and Italian.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 11/02/1511:38 PM
All the Koreans in Queens were too busy staffing Jack shacks in the tri-state area to go to the game. The coloreds to lazy to go, the jews too cheap and the mexicans were too busy working.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 11/02/1511:41 PM
Originally Posted By: the unknown pervert
BTW does anyone still want to complain about the voting in the All-Star Game?
Dude, you won, enjoy it and don't ruin the good feelings people are having towards the Royals. Them books were cooked.
Personally I'd like to see the All Star game be USA vs The World and have the foreign players against the Americans. There is interleague play every day now, so AL v. NL is old news.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 11/09/1503:45 PM
Well, one more plus from going to the Series. I get a week's worth of free coffee because I brought back a commemorative shot glass to give to the only hot barista I know who likes baseball.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/06/1607:15 PM
I feel good for both of them. Griffey now has the highest % vote total in HOF history, edging out Met's great Tom Seaver. So does Piazza go in with a Mets cap or a Dodger's cap? His preference is for the Mets.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/06/1611:12 PM
440 votes cast-
437 Ken Griffey Jr. 99.3% HOF 365 Mike Piazza 83.0% HOF
315 Jeff Bagwell 71.6% 307 Tim Raines 69.8% 296 Trevor Hoffman 67.3% 230 Curt Schilling 52.3% 199 Roger Clemens 45.2% 195 Barry Bonds 44.3% 191 Edgar Martinez 43.4% 189 Mike Mussina 43.0% 180 Alan Trammell 40.9% Last year on ballot 150 Lee Smith 34.1% 92 Fred McGriff 20.9% 73 Jeff Kent 16.6% 68 Larry Walker 15.5% 54 Mark McGwire 12.3% Last year on ballot 51 Gary Sheffield 11.6% 46 Billy Wagner 10.5% 31 Sammy Sosa 7.0%
Eliminated from consideration
11 Jim Edmonds 2.5% 8 Nomar Garciaparra 1.8% 3 Mike Sweeney 0.7% 2 David Eckstein 0.5% 2 Jason Kendall 0.5% 1 Garret Anderson 0.2% 0 Brad Ausmus 0.0% 0 Luis Castillo 0.0% 0 Troy Glaus 0.0% 0 Mark Grudzielanek 0.0% 0 Mike Hampton 0.0% 0 Mike Lowell 0.0% 0 Randy Winn 0.0%
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/08/1611:20 AM
Curt Schilling had this to say about whether or not he should be in the Hall: "By my criteria, no—I’m not. I’ve always thought that Hall of Famers are people that you don’t debate about." I'd tend to agree with that. If you have to ask the question, then they shouldn't get in.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 04/04/1607:56 AM
Tell Harvey to wear a rubber when he's getting birthday butt from a ho and he won't get a UTI. If he has to bare back em, pee right after and drink some cranberry juice.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 04/05/1607:55 PM
At least we have one pitcher who has shown he can beat Kansas City. I really would've loved for the Series to make it to Game 7 last year just to see what would've happened. Oh well, it is what it is. Nice win today.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 04/05/1608:34 PM
Wow, it's possible. I just checked the over/under for wins for the Phillies and they range from 65-66.5. And the Braves are sposed to be just as bad, if not worse.
Currently debating whether or not to place a bet with one of my friends as to whether or not the Mets will reach 90 wins this season. He still owes me a steak dinner for the Mets making the playoffs last year, so I'm gonna wait until we go out to eat before I decide on whether or not to bet this year.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 04/05/1609:05 PM
The Mets should kill the NL East this season. I've been a lifelong Phillies fan. You know that MLB Extra Innings is free this week right? I think that I had the Mets winning 92 games this season.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 05/08/1601:34 AM
The Mets must be truly blessed. Bartolo Colon, the fattest, oldest player in the league hit a home run today. No player in MLB history has hit their first home run at his age. My hero. And he rolled a baseball right to me across the top of the dugout during last year's World Series. Just look at the athleticism:
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 05/12/1607:29 PM
Originally Posted By: windsock
Sorry. That was intended for CPG's JOFA thread. Can somebody move it or get rid of it?
Originally Posted By: Jerkules
You can delete your own posts, just click edit, then delete post. I don't think we can move/merge single posts, just threads.
I know Lou and H2C used to do it, but I don't think they had the system crashing down upon them like you've got today. Not your doing, of course. Anyway, more for the XXXXPornTalk thread.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 05/12/1609:43 PM
Originally Posted By: Raoul Duke
Originally Posted By: windsock
Sorry. That was intended for CPG's JOFA thread. Can somebody move it or get rid of it?
Originally Posted By: Jerkules
You can delete your own posts, just click edit, then delete post. I don't think we can move/merge single posts, just threads.
I know Lou and H2C used to do it, but I don't think they had the system crashing down upon them like you've got today. Not your doing, of course. Anyway, more for the XXXXPornTalk thread.
I might make a couple shit threads in the Gimp Box and play around w/ moving single posts. I don't want to try moving a post out of an established thread and fucking something up.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 06/26/1602:58 PM
Just imagine where we'd be without the pitching. On the flip side, imagine where we'd be with a bit more hitting. Probably 5 games up on the Nats.
I don't miss Murph as much as I dislike him being on the Nats and helping them out. After the W.S. last year, I was telling someone he should sign with an AL club and he'd prolly hit .400 if he didn't have to think about fielding. I think I was right. The Mets announcers used to always tell a story about Murphy and how he introduced himself when all the minor league guys showed up and gave out their names and positions. His response, "I'm Daniel Murphy and I hit third." He got us to the World Series last year though before the magic wore off. I would've been happy if he came back, but our current second baseman is having a career year and can actually field the position.
I'm hoping Wright after neck surgery doesn't turn into Nick Markakis after neck surgery. But I really don't see him as a starter anymore after having both back & neck issues. I hope I'm wrong and I'd love for him to come back, but there's a reason the Mets are having a workout with the best 3rd baseman from Cuba next week.
No idea what Reyes has left in the tank, but I do think he improves the team even if it's just with his energy and enthusiasm for being back in NY.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 06/26/1609:03 PM
Murphy would be your 3rd baseman, not 2nd. I dont see how they move forward counting on Wright.
I knew Murphy's stats would explode away from CitiField. That is why i figured Wright would bolt to a team like the Orioles back when he was a free agent. He would be borderline HOF by now if he did the last 4-5yrs in a band box.
The Wilpon family that owned the Mets was in big with Madoff, and thought that an annuitized deferral at 5% interest would net them cash because Madoff was promising a 10% annual return. Still, he makes more than deGrom and Harvey.
Anyway, the rumor is that Bonilla is perpetually out of money and spends most of what he gets each year. If he had saved one of those checks in 2000 when the DJIA was around 8,000, he'd have doubled his money by now, at least.
Look on the bright side: he didn't hire Lenny Dykstra as his broker.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 07/04/1608:47 PM
Shit, I think I read that we're still paying Darryl Strawberry. Great comeback win today, down 6-0 to the Marlin's and won 8-6. Matt Harvey can thank the bullpen for keeping him from becoming a career .500 pitcher. Huge 4 game sweep of the Cubs this past week also.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/13/1709:55 PM
Originally Posted By: charin
Bagwell, Raines, Hoffman, Pudge
No way Pudge gets in on the first ballot. HOffman is hamstrung by being a reliever, he will be scrutinized extra. Raines is on his last year of eligibility. If he hasn't made it by now, it probably won't happen. He can speak with Alan Trammell about that.
Bagwell is the closest to a ticket. He got snubbed last year because of Junior. This should be his year.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 01/18/1706:01 PM
Bagwell juiced to the gills, as did I-rod.
Raines isnt a HOF er. Outstandimg player but not a HOFer
BBWA has thrned into nothing but a bunch of nerds casting votes for names they remember from childhood. Raines Smoltz & Rice going in the past few uears are right up there w/ some of the Old Timers Committee abominations of the past.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 10/03/1701:16 PM
Yanks over Twins tonight. But who knows, anything can happen in one game, it's fucked up. Astros over Red Sox in ALDS Indians over Yanks in ALDS Indians over Astros in ALCS
D-backs over Rockies tomorrow Nats over Cubs in NLDS Dodgers over D-backs in NLDS Dodgers over Nats in NLCS
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 10/07/1712:38 PM
Originally Posted By: charin
Yanks over Twins tonight. But who knows, anything can happen in one game, it's fucked up. Astros over Red Sox in ALDS Indians over Yanks in ALDS Indians over Astros in ALCS
D-backs over Rockies tomorrow Nats over Cubs in NLDS Dodgers over D-backs in NLDS Dodgers over Nats in NLCS
Dodgers over Indians in WS
Aaron Judge just gonna win ROY & MVP or they figure out a way to give him the Cy Youngn, also?
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 11/22/1702:08 AM
Here is the list of eligible players:
Player Year on ballot Last vote %
Trevor Hoffman Vladimir Guerrero Edgar Martinez Roger Clemens Barry Bonds Mike Mussina Curt Schilling Manny Ramirez Larry Walker Fred McGriff Jeff Kent Gary Sheffield Billy Wagner Sammy Sosa Chipper Jones Jim Thome Scott Rolen Omar Vizquel Johan Santana Andruw Jones Johnny Damon Jamie Moyer Chris Carpenter Kerry Wood Carlos Zambrano Livan Hernandez Orlando Hudson Aubrey Huff Jason Isringhausen Carlos Lee Brad Lidge Hideki Matsui Kevin Millwood
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 11/22/1702:30 AM
Chipper will get in. To me, Chipper isn't a first ballot guy, as he hits none of the big milestones, but will get in on the first ballot w/ the TBS assist.
Vlad should have been in last year and will get in this time. Some amazing seasons wasted in Montreal.
Hoffman should get in. Being the 2nd best closer of his time, behind Mariano, shouldn't hold him back. A closer that good for that long deserves the plaque.
Thome probably get in yr 2 or 3. Visquel get in eventually.
Mussina, McGriff and Matsui probably never sniff the Hall, but I wish they would.
Mussina has way better career stats than Smoltz & Halladay (everyone been sayin he's a HOFer).
McGriff fell just short of 500HRs, and the steroid #s of the late 90s/early 00s diminish what a feared power hitter he was.
Matsui wasn't in MLB long enough. Projected out to 20yrs in the league and he would get in.
Martinez I am up in the air about. Damon is kinda close but a No.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 11/24/1708:44 PM
WAR is for nerds who suck dick. They tout it, yet can't explain how it is determined. Then you got the issue that different places calculate it differently. BaseballReference had Altuve leading the league in WAR, but FanGraphs had Judge.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 11/27/1709:26 AM
Murphy fell apart after he got that berry cut off his face. He was probably a big season or 2 away from the Hall. Back to back MVPs though, and a catcher who became a gold glove center fielder.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/11/1702:03 PM
I think both are marginal, but I'm OK with them.
Morris was the ace wherever he pitched, was a finisher, has rings with 3 teams. 3.90 lifetime ERA in the Hall? Well...
Trammel had a very good glove at SS to go with those numbers. I was a big advocate of Barry Larkin for the Hall, if he is in, Trammel deserves it, too. Larkin was an All-Star twice as many times - was Trammel ever the best SS in the league?
I dunno about the "Modern Era" stuff. It's marginal, too.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 12/11/1703:40 PM
Neither should be in the HOF, and I say that w/ great respect for Morris' big game ability, the 10inning shutout of the Braves in game 7 possibly being the best pressure pitching performance in my lifetime.
Trammel wasn't even a perennial All-Star, making 6 in 20yrs. Never close to the best at his position, w/ Ripken and Ozzie around.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 10/20/1812:44 AM
Sad that the Yankees lost to the BoSux, but w/ all the injuries they had this year, they were lucky to get as far as they did.
Series also showed that relying so heavily on HRs makes the playoffs tough. Stanton would be getting ripped to shreds by 80s era, liquored up Steinbrenner. Really hoping that it was just a 1yr stop over, and he's getting traded to the Dodgers in the off season.
I hope Didi's Tommy John surgery doesn't make the front office panic and sign Machado. Team is too right handed already. Better off to let Gleyber play SS, and sign Murphy to a 3yr deal to split time between 2nd, 1st and DH. Other than that, I'd rather Machado money be spent on Starting Pitchers.
Re: If I had a Hall of Fame ballot ... - 08/07/1903:39 AM
Just wanted to stop in and say that Mariano Rivera was annoited the Greatest Hall Of Famer of All Time, via unanimous induction this year.
I don't expect the same done for Captain Derek Jeter next year, because so many other towns, and their writers, got dick issues with NYC and the Yankees. Also, the rebuild of the Marlins will hurt him. #6 on the all time hit list, dude is a lay up, though.